Multiple Language and Cultural Self-Identities of the German-Speaking Lutheran Minorities in Russian Poland (Mazowsze Suvalkija) in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries By Cynthia Vakarelyska

uoregon.academia.edu/CynthiaMVakareliyska

Another early follower of this blog, researcher, A. S, told me about this article in the early days of the blog. I found it most intriguing and after reading it, made some observations. At the same time I contacted the author and found a very gracious professional interested in the work of a serious amateur. In a series of four posts, I share these observations with personal comments: Introduction, Polish-Texts, Russia, Conclusions and Notes.

http://www.academia.edu/1339604/Multiple_language_and_cultural_self-identities_of_the_German-speaking_Lutheran_minorities_in_Russian_Poland_Mazowsze_and_Suvalkija_in_the_nineteenth_

You can download the first part of the article as a pdf by providing your e-mail. If you want to read the entire article, you must sign up which I did in order to provide the following comments. Because they were made from a personal standpoint, another researcher may find a different perspective from reading the whole article.

INTRODUCTION:
1. By far the most important information is a reaffirmation of the ethnicity of the –at names: Endnote 5: “German truncation of Lithuanian suffixes – aitis, -aite to –at, eyt; etc.

2. First 3 paragraphs on page 195 give a summary of the “Russian Germans” (do not often see this term) now primarily (later she states 2/3) in southwestern Lithuania.

They were part of the settlements in the late 18 and early 19th centuries by Catherine II and Paul I. Do not often see this written either. Suwalki settled by sizable groups from Salzburg and Alsace Lorraine.

This supports my idea of when they came to Suwalki: at the time of the Third Partition in 1795.

Says Suwalki was never part of Prussia but part of it was part of New East Prussia from 1795 to 1805. Others have said 1807.

3. Lutheran liturgy, Sunday School, and Confirmation all contributed to the continued use reading and speaking the German language.

Fits the Spurgats to the final t!

4. Two sources of info on this area include: Heberle’s 1927 sociological comparison of German groups in various parts of Lithuania and Rolf Brandt’s (1915 to 1936) fictional and documentary novels based on soldiers’ experiences in WWI.

Both agree that Suwalki Germans considered themselves a culturally distinct group from Germans in Germany and East Prussia. They got along well with their Polish, Russian, and Jewish neighbors and did not feel any political allegiance to Germany.

This information supports the stories that have come from one of the three Spurgat families.

5. In WWI these German “colonists” were sent to Russia.

In the collection of statistics of these people the terms German and Lutheran were used interchangeably.

Many different ethnic groups lived and worked close together. By the early 19th century there was already significant intermarriage with other groups. By the mid 19th century these Russian Germans appear to have a native or near native proficiency in Polish. Some knew Russian and Yiddish.

This info supports the stories that have come from one of the three Spurgat families.

6. Among themselves (1927) they talked in Polish, Russian, or Lithuanian.

Two factors secured their identity as Germans: 1. The German language was used at home and at church. 2. Lutheranism.

Fits the Spurgats to the final t!

7. “There was a duty to one’s family history to ensure that both the language and the confession were passed on to future generations within the family, even in instances of intermarriage with other groups.”

I have said in my book that somewhere along the line, perhaps a German woman married a Spurgat, a Lithuanian name, and the family assumed the religion of the mother. That was how the Spurgats became Lutheran.

8. Even those with Polish or Lithuanian names or of mixed ancestry described themselves as German into the early 20th century.

Fits the Spurgats to the final t!

9. The rest of the article examines the “interference” of the various languages used in the parish records of the Marijampole Lutheran Church, the Seirjai Protestant (Lutheran and Reformed) Church, and the Sakiai and Prienai Lutheran churches with respect to the accuracy and authenticity with which the records were kept in the official language, Polish, and later Russian. How much German (and Polish) was inserted into the records and what do those insertions tell us about the language as used in its written and spoken form?